Back to Stories
General Fiction

The Courage to Question

Not every truth we carry was discovered. Some were simply handed to us.

Heather WickhamMarch 30, 202634 views
The Courage to Question
I have always found the human mind fascinating.
Two people can walk through the same moment and leave with entirely different truths. The same event, the same words spoken, the same air in the room, yet the meaning each carries away can be worlds apart.
Which makes me wonder how much of what we believe is truly ours.
Most beliefs arrive long before we are old enough to question them. They come through parents, teachers, religion, culture, authority. They are passed down quietly, generation to generation, like heirlooms no one remembers choosing.
We inherit them.
And most of the time, we never examine them.
The strange thing is that the people who gave us those beliefs did not create them either. They were given to them by someone else, who received them from someone before that. A long chain of borrowed certainty stretching backward through time.
Somewhere along the way, those ideas become sacred.
Untouchable.
Questioning them can feel almost like disobedience.
But if you step back and look closely, a troubling realization begins to emerge.
We are often not thinking for ourselves at all.
We are simply repeating what we were taught.
In many ways, we are domesticated on someone else’s truth.
Trained to accept the map without ever asking who drew it.
My mind never worked that way.
Even as a child, if something did not make sense, it stayed with me. I could not just nod and move on. The question would sit there in my thoughts like an unsolved riddle. I would turn it over, examine it from every angle, searching for the missing piece.
That habit drove a lot of adults crazy.
What they wanted was agreement.
What I wanted was understanding.
If something did not add up, I asked about it. If the answers still did not make sense, I looked deeper. I read more. I listened more. I tried to understand the foundation beneath the belief.
And often I discovered something uncomfortable.
Many ideas people defend with absolute certainty were never examined in the first place.
They were simply inherited.
It is easier to accept the world as it is explained to you than it is to dismantle the explanation and rebuild it from the ground up.
Certainty is comfortable.
Curiosity is disruptive.
But every advancement humanity has ever made began with someone willing to challenge what everyone else accepted without question. Someone looked at the world and said, This doesn’t quite make sense. And instead of silencing that thought, they followed it.
Maybe the greatest strength of the human mind is not its ability to memorize what it is told.
Maybe its real power lies in its willingness to question it.
Because the moment we begin to examine what we were given, we begin the slow process of becoming something other than domesticated.
Something capable of discovering truth for ourselves.
Because the moment we begin to question what we were taught,
we take the first step toward becoming fully human.

Reviews (3)

Sign in to leave a review

Berniethebard

3/30/2026

The Words That Got to Me

A very philosophical piece of writing, one which bears the hallmarks of your style. And one which neatly summarises some of what your other writing has said. I have read it in two sections. But I stress that is down to me and my personality. The whole time I was reading your first part which for me ends with "trained to accept the map ........" I felt uncomfortable because the thought that this was true really got to me. Once you said "my mind never worked that way" I was in a happier place. I believe there are some of us who are not the result of our genes or our upbringing, some of us who had this innate sense that this wasn't right. You were one of those if you don't mind me saying. Just as I was. This is not to say I wasn't influenced because I was, influenced but never persuaded is the best way I can put it. So I guess what I am.saying in a long winded way is that what you have written makes complete sense to me and therefore resonates. The one part of your piece that doesn't really convince me is the start. If you started with "how much of what we believe is truly ours" i feel it would be better but that is just my opinion.

Thank you. I really appreciated this response and the way you explained it. What you said about being influenced but never fully persuaded really resonated with me. That felt like such an honest and accurate way to put it. And thank you too for the suggestion on the opening. I can definitely see your point, and I’m sitting with it. I always appreciate the thought you put into your reads. They never feel rushed or surface-level.

The Words That Got to Me

This was a strong start to the piece: Two people can walk through the same moment and leave with entirely different truths. The same event, the same words spoken, the same air in the room, yet the meaning each carries away can be worlds apart. I thought your examination of the way in which we are made up of other people's thoughts and impressions was spot on. We inherit so much in the way of attitudes and beliefs, without realising it. This hit me with a bang as this is what I have been noticing strongly lately in my reactions and thoughts, and those of a family member. In my experience, it is the difference between a positive and a negative framework.

Suggestions / Possible Tweaks

I really liked the parts where you told us more about you and your experiences, for example, That habit drove a lot of adults crazy. What they wanted was agreement. What I wanted was understanding. I found myself wanted more of that personal touch.

I thought this an extremely interesting piece, one that encouraged me to think about what I inherited, and what I questioned.

The Words That Got to Me

Most beliefs arrive long before we are old enough to question them. They come through parents, teachers, religion, culture, authority. They are passed down quietly, generation to generation, like heirlooms no one remembers choosing. **How am I this old and yet have NEVER given this a moment's thought? I have NEVER arrived at this common sense conclusion! In many ways, we are domesticated on someone else’s truth. *This filled me with an image of a stallion being turned into a plow horse. Very sobering. Even as a child, if something did not make sense, it stayed with me. I could not just nod and move on. The question would sit there in my thoughts like an unsolved riddle. I would turn it over, examine it from every angle, searching for the missing piece. That habit drove a lot of adults crazy. *I've told you this before, but this was one more example of it for me: I SOO, sooo, SOOOO wish I'd known you as a little girl, because I would NEVER have driven me crazy! I'd have ADORED such a sparking mind and all the questions it created. What a waste of an obviously special little girl! Grrrrrr! Maybe the greatest strength of the human mind is not its ability to memorize what it is told. Maybe its real power lies in its willingness to question it. j*I completely agree with this. If you look at the "great minds" throughout time, it's always the ones who questioned the established who improved everyone's quality of life.

You have the depth and wisdom of an old woman. Your ability to (a) notice and (b) assess situations presented to you stun me. You're so extremely spot-on. This was tremendously well done. xoxo

Thank you so much for this. Your words really meant a lot to me. That image of the stallion being turned into a plow horse was honestly such a powerful way to put it. It felt like you reached right into what I was trying to say and gave it an image. That quiet shaping that happens before we are even old enough to realize it is happening is such a sobering thing to really sit with. And as beautiful as it would have been to have someone not get frustrated with me or act like I was aggravating just because I wanted to understand, I also sometimes wonder if the very way I think was born from the lack of that kind of support. Maybe having to sit alone with so many unanswered questions is part of what made me into someone who could not stop turning things over and looking deeper. When I read the beginning of your memoir and you talked about the little boy who had a hard time behaving, and the way his teacher handled him, I thought that was so beautiful and so rare. We need more teachers like that. I am sure there were so many children who benefited from your understanding that behavior is not what makes someone good or bad. A lot of the time, the ones struggling the most are the very ones who need the most love. I think for me, more than anything, I just wanted to be seen without being judged. And I truly hope education can keep evolving in a way that helps neurodivergent students actually learn instead of just being labeled. There is so much brilliance in minds that work differently, and too often the system treats different like defective. That has never sat right with me. Thank you again for this. It really touched me.

I agree with every last word of that, Heather. xoxo