Back to Stories
Mystery/Thriller

Role Model

A terrifying mother/daughter getaway

Rachelle AllenApril 5, 202653 views
Role Model

                                   

 

 

          I am sitting across from my daughter in the kitchen of our favorite retreat, a mountainside cabin I bought three summers ago. It’s ensconced in a circle of lush pines and just a five-minute walk to a deep, wide lake as blue as cornflowers. The nearest town is a good ten miles away, exactly how we like it on these mother-daughter bonding excursions that we take three or four times a year.

          As Lila talks, I respond with warmth and animation that are less than sincere because I now know that my child, this smart, pretty over-achiever before me, is also a dangerous sociopath. The web of her lies is so dense that their filaments could produce a flawless lace tablecloth the size of a football field.

          For two more days, until we return to the city, I will act both engaged in her charm and oblivious to what I know is the awful truth: She’s stowed at least four bodies on the far side of the lake in a culvert she covered, like a mass grave, with fronds and branches from the nearby vegetation.

          I’ve surmised that this is the work of my daughter rather than some crazed psychopath rooting around in these woods because one body is, even with decay, still intact enough for me to recognize. He’s the stockbroker she brought home two weekends ago and whom she said, through tears the next day, was moving to England. Another cadaver is a fresh kill: the waitress with whose services Lila was dissatisfied less than twenty-four hours ago.

          To my advantage, I make my living in the creative and performing arts, which means that I excel in taking on the role of characters foreign to my nature. I have, in fact, received many awards for it throughout my thirty-five years in the business. On Sunday, when Lila returns us home – her to her apartment in the city, me to our family house two suburbs beyond – then I can feel the rush of emotions that, for the sake of self-preservation, I am compartmentalizing right now: fear, horror, disbelief, betrayal, rage, and shame. I have obviously taught her well how to be a chameleon, for she has fooled us all beyond belief. Right now, in fact, she is talking about her childhood fear of rats and mice while two miles from our cabin is the detritus of her unthinkable acts.

          To my disadvantage, cell service doesn’t extend this far into the wilderness, and Lila is fit, athletic, and twenty-five years my junior. Never could I outrun or overpower her. My only protection is my ability to beat her at her own craft: acting as if everything is fine and normal when I know excruciatingly well that it couldn’t be sicker. One slip, and I’ll be Body No. Five.

          This will have to be the performance of my life and the ultimate game of chess.

                                                  #

          As always on our first night in the cabin, I prepare her favorite meal – roast chicken with sweet potatoes and a cucumber-and-tomato salad – then challenge her to a game of Scrabble. We laugh and cajole each other with every new word on the board. I remind her of the first time she beat me. “It wasn’t until I was sixteen, though,” she remarks, a rueful pout on her face.

          “Yes, but you knew it was a genuine victory because I’ve never believed in just letting children win.”

          “I’m going to do that when I have children,” she muses. I give her a doting smile as my stomach leaks acid into my throat.

          “Isn’t it time for marshmallows in the fire pit?” I tease like a whiny child.

          “Nooooo,” Lila admonishes like a strict mother. “We save that for our last night.” She then switches gears in a way that concerns me. “Want to go out and dangle our feet in the lake?”

          “At night?” I squawk. “Are you kidding? Lila Maynard, you know that once it’s dark, I venture no further than the fire pit on the back deck. Don’t you remember our first time here when we made the mistake of shining our headlights into the dark? All those wolves came running out from the woods and started to circle the truck? And then further out, we could see about three hundred more pairs of yellow eyes glowing back at us.”

          “It was the headlights that brought them out,” Lila says with some exasperation in her tone. Then, with a finality and edginess to her voice, she says, “Well, I’m going,” and I am chilled but still offer up a protest.

          “Sweetie, no,” I coo, my character full of maternal concern for her, as I would have had, myself, were I not aware of what’s decomposing in the woods.

          “I said I’m going,” Lila snaps with an irascibility and impatience to her tone, and I know this dialogue is over. For whatever reason – to admire her cache again, perhaps, or maybe just to check that it remains undisturbed – she needs to venture out to her quarry.

          “Take the extra flashlight, at least,” I say with the perfect combination of caring and resignation, and she obliges without a backward glance.

          As the door closes, I see her keys lying on the table, and an electric current encircles each of my vertebrae and, one by one, ignites the hairs on the back of my neck. This is a test. Her instinct has sensed what I know.

          I pad to the living room and pretend to be absorbed in my book while, in fact, all my senses are on their highest alert. Will she be sneaking around to the back deck to overtake me if I try to drive to safety? Or is she already lying in wait for me in the van? My continuing to lie on this couch, turning pages in a book on which I couldn’t possibly be concentrating, is my only chance of living through the night with my child. I will give it thirty minutes then open a window and call out to her, to make her hear how I am growing concerned for her safety.

          Bullfrogs from the lake and crickets in surround-sound combine in an eerie, unsettling orchestration, magnified by the amphitheater they call home. But it’s when they stop in unison that my terror is magnified. Exponentially, in fact, because I sense what’s causing it. Yet my lifetime of training in the theater recognizes a cue when one presents itself to me, and this one is deafening in its silence.

                    A mother’s instinct would be kicking in, and so I take the stage in case a career-ending

            critic is lurking in the wings.

          I spring to a sitting position then lean forward, giving a slow turn of my head, brows and eyes at the furtive best. I lay my book on the arm of our couch and give both the appearance and the reality of listening. I steal on crouching legs to the front window for effect, since that is the direction my child went when she left. If she is peering in through the back window, this will look like the act of an oblivious, concerned mother.

          I call out with a high, tight tone that doesn’t require a lot of acting to effectuate.

          “Lila? Sweetie? You okay?”

          Silence.

          Louder this time, and with a quaver, I make it sound as if I’m panicking. Again, there is little acting needed. “Lila? Lila! Please answer me. Sweetie, please. Are....you....okay?”

          “Mommy?” Lila’s voice rasps out from what I sense is the edge of the pine trees.

          “What is it, Sweetie? Are you hurt?” My heart pounds so hard into my ears, I have trouble hearing anything.

          “Mommy, please help me,” she implores.

          “Honey, I will help, but I can’t see you. Turn your flashlights on.”

          Silence again and blackness still.

          “Oh, Lila, please Sweetie; I can’t see you to know where to come and help you.” Prickles of terror are stabbing the entire surface of my head. I begin to sweat.

          “I’m too scared to do that, Mommy,” she says with the voice of a child. And then, through the nightmare-black air, I can hear her whimpering.

          “No, no,” I say. “Don’t cry, Lila. Just please turn on your flashlights.”

          A long beat hangs in the smothering air before I see two wide circles of halogen light arc out from my daughter’s hands and into the molten eyes of the wolf pack that surrounds her.

          The lights hypnotize the ones positioned at three and nine, but they send the other ten into attack mode. Lila screams and screams and screams, an operatic obligato to the low, guttural snaps and growls that encircle her. And then the screaming stops, and even from this distance, the sound of a feeding frenzy is unmistakable.

          I return to the living room and start a fire, and, while it begins to swell, I make my way to the kitchen for a bag of marshmallows.

Reviews (5)

Sign in to leave a review

The Words That Got to Me

Oh my word! What an engrossing and psychological roller-coaster that was! You lured me in with the cosy idea of a mother/daughter bonding trip - 'our favorite retreat... ensconced in a circle of lush pines and just a five-minute walk to a deep, wide lake as blue as cornflowers. ' How lovely, I thought. Then came the shock of the 2nd paragraph - Daughter ='dangerous sociopath' 'I have obviously taught her well how to be a chameleon' - this drew me further into the twisted dynamics of this relationship and made me start to feel uneasy about the narrator's personality too. 'This will have to be the performance of my life and the ultimate game of chess' - this was a great line for setting up the battle of wills ahead. Lines such as 'this will look like the act of an oblivious, concerned mother' showed us how much the narrator was acting a part - perhaps a role she had practised for many years. 'I give her a doting smile as my stomach leaks acid into my throat' - I absolutely loved the opposing images here - love and revulsion/fear.

Suggestions / Possible Tweaks

'acting a if everything is fine and normal' - a should be 'as'. In the phrases, 'case a career-ending critic is lurking in the wings.' and 'make my way to the kitchen for a bag of marshmallows' the positioning has gone a little out of whack.

I absolutely loved this truly horrible horror story! It gripped me from beginning to end. The veneer of a mumsy/daughter bonding trip soon disappeared, revealing something far more disturbing and sinister. The part about the toads going silent was masterful - I was literally on the edge of my seat. I loved the twist with the mum heading for the marshmallows. I'm now worried about my own psychological state as I actually let out a laugh at the end, after all that tension and suspense! The title is absolutely perfect, summing up the roles being played out here, and the way the mother has been a role model for sociopathic tendencies all along.

One of most-often used phrases as an educator is: You plant corn, you get corn. This is the poster child example story! Thanks for your enthusiastic review! Xoxoxo And thanks for spotting the formatting glitches, too. (How does that even HAPPEN if I copy-and-paste? I swear I will never acclimate to cyberspace!

Tim Margetts

4/6/2026

The Words That Got to Me

This story has an excellent premise, combining revelation and trap, which makes the tale immediately compelling. You use a consistent voice that keeps the whole sordid affair believable. "This will have to be the performance of my life and the ultimate game of chess." is an excellent line that clearly sets out the stakes. "But it’s when they [frogs and crickets] stop in unison that my terror is magnified." a classic but very effective device to increase the tension.

Suggestions / Possible Tweaks

There is quite a bit where show, not tell, especially in the early part of the story, falls down, for example, you tell me directly that – She is a dangerous sociopath – She has killed multiple people – The mother has identified bodies – The mother is pretending There are also a few small technical issues: – “acting a if everything is fine” should be “acting as if” – “perfectcombination” missing space – “whiney” should be “whiny” – A few sentences are quite long and could be broken for rhythm and tension.

I see this as a bit of a tale where 'the apple didn't fall far from the tree'. The mother's actions, more and more, lead me to believe she is also a psychopath. I cant say from this if she is also a murderer, but she acted in several ways to suggest she may be. Her reference to teaching her chameleon abilities, the way she compartmentalises, while maybe a survival trait, could also be her own acknowledgement of her own darker personalities. Finally, the way she acts so calm as her own daughter is torn apart and eaten alive, and returns to the family holiday activity of marshmallow toasting is particularly chilling.

Thank you for all this helpful and skilled feedback. I especially appreciate the spag-catches. You read with such an editor's eye. Lucky me!! Thanks very much for always being a great reviewer. I love to read your take on my stories. xoxo

The Words That Got to Me

I should have, but I absolutely did not see the ending coming. Great job also of building suspense from the time Lila leaves until "the feeding". I love lines in your story like this... I give her a doting smile as my stomach leaks acid into my throat. and...acting as if everything is fine and normal when I know excruciatingly well that it couldn’t be sicker.

Suggestions / Possible Tweaks

I do feel like the mother getting the marshmallows doesn't quite fit the tone you have created for the mom. She wants to live through the ordeal, but she seems to not be so cold toward her child as to eat a treat right after "the feeding". I think it would be much more believable and horrifying if she just sat back on the couch relieved. The horror is in listening to her daughter scream and leaving her out there to die. And to watch as the wolves feed. I also feel like in the following line...The web of her lies is so dense that their filaments could produce a flawless lace tablecloth the size of a football field...that football field brought me out of the story because that didn't fit the tone you were writing or the imagery you were building in that sentence. The following passage is in the way of the story. It is confusing and breaks the timely suspense you are beginning to build... On Sunday, when Lila returns us home – her to her apartment in the city, me to our family house two suburbs beyond – then I can feel the rush of emotions that, for the sake of self-preservation, I am compartmentalizing right now: fear, horror, disbelief, betrayal, rage, and shame.

You have such a jewel here, I think with some more editing it will be extraordinary in full.

Thanks for the feedback, Michaela. The marshmallows was supposed to chill you. I wanted the reader to think, "OMG; the mother's as bad as the daughter." A you-plant-corn-you-get-corn realization that then (horrifyingly) ties in the title, "Role Model." I wanted the reader to then reflect back on the signs, most especially the Scrabble games and the mother's comment about not believing in "letting" a child win. They're both ghastly people.

Katharine

5/28/2026

The Words That Got to Me

...Her instinct has sensed what I know. The web of her lies is so dense that their filaments could produce a flawless lace tablecloth the size of a football field. No, no,” I say. “Don’t cry, Lila. Just please turn on your flashlights.” with your knowing full well what that will do to the wolves. The second to last paragraph is the most sinister thing I think I've ever read! You sure you're not kin to Edgar Allen...???

Good grief, Rachelle! Talk about a hook and a surprise ending! I was so worried for "you"--I had you in mind, of course, as the protag. And there you were, planning your own daughter's demise. Although I have to admit, it took me a while to realize you were actually orchestrating her death! That is a masterful horror story; and if it were a play, I can really see you in that part. However, I wonder how many of us who have read it will have nightmares. If there are different versions of horror, I'd call this one, sadistic! But brilliant! :)

The Words That Got to Me

My only protection is my ability to beat her at her own craft: acting as if everything is fine and normal when I know excruciatingly well that it couldn’t be sicker. One slip, and I’ll be Body No. Five. Aren't you the actress of the year! This will have to be the performance of my life and the ultimate game of chess. ah yes, you agree.

Suggestions / Possible Tweaks

I do have a question. How do the people the mom killed have anything to do with her? Oh. lordie, just saw that I had already commented before. sorry.

Oh, my God, Rachelle! You fooled me right up to the end. That is one hell of a story! Morbid and gross, (ha!) but the height of suspense. Such a caring mom - your character. Can't help but think of the mom in the news who killed her three small children. Anyway, you build a plot well that, naturally, points to the daughter, and I'm feeling so concerned for you, and then....You're a sly one! Very skillfully done!

edited 8/30/2026